Bitterroot Mountains
Find Us on TV


To John Goedde, saying 'no' means 'not yet'

Marty Trillhaase
April 1, 2013
Lewiston Tribune

Five months ago, the people of Idaho said no.

No to overturning teachers' employment rights - 57 percent.

No to imposing a top-down merit pay system rewarding teachers more for whether they work in a wealthy school than what they do - 58 percent.

No to pulling money meant for teacher salaries to pay for an untested technology initiative - 66.7 percent.

When state school Superintendent Tom Luna was cramming this 2011 overhaul package down the throats of Idaho parents, students, teachers, and taxpayers, Sen. John Goedde, R-Coeur d'Alene, was helping him every step of the way.

Since November's referendum campaign, Goedde, chairman of the Senate Education Committee, has taken any opportunity to get even with the voters for repudiating his handiwork.

If there's a bill to continue weakening teacher collective bargaining rights, he's on board.

When the Farm Bureau came up with a scheme to weaken Idaho's initiative/referendum process, Goedde voted yes.

When the Legislature's Office of Performance Evaluations reported a "strong undercurrent of despair among teachers who seem to perceive a climate that disparages their efforts and belittles their contributions," Goedde told teachers to take a happy pill.

"If I walk into this building on Monday morning feeling good, and everybody I talk to says, 'You're looking bad,' maybe I start feeling bad. I think despair is contagious, as is enthusiasm - it's a state of mind," Goedde said.

And last week, Goedde delivered the coup d'├ętat - defeating a $1.3 billion public school appropriation bill by an 18-17 Senate vote. Lawmakers haven't rejected a school funding bill in 21 years. The maneuver has thrown the Legislature into a tizzy. Lawmakers thought Good Friday would be their last day in Boise. Now they're back for April's Fools Day.

But the question is: Why did he do it?

Goedde says the budget-writing committee usurped its authority by allocating about $34 million in money freed up when the Luna laws were repealed. Budget writers put $8.4 million into teacher training, $12.6 million toward a grass-roots-designed merit pay bonus system and $13 million toward technology, most of it in the classroom.

Such policies, Goedde says, should have been decided by his committee.

"I was the education chair that was not included in the grand compromise," He said.

So that's it?


Goedde's peeved because he didn't get his say over 2.6 percent of a $1.3 billion package?

Except he did.

His committee was given time to study the measure. Goedde's suggestions got incorporated into the final budget bill.

Could it possibly be something else?

For instance, is Goedde's miffed at the reversal of the Luna package's most odious feature - pulling about $12.4 million from pay owed to teachers? Under that provision, teachers got less money for longevity and training. For instance, a teacher with five years of experience was compensated as if she had been on the job for only three years.

Chiseling teachers freed up money for Luna's other priorities.

After voters rejected that approach, a coalition of 15 Democrats, Senate moderates and House Republicans on the budget panel restored the money.

But not everybody got the message. Five of Goedde's Senate allies on the budget panel - including Sen. Sheryl Nuxoll, R-Cottonwood - disregarded the voters' mandate.

When Goedde made his move against the school bill, those five Republicans supported him.

So keep an eye on Goedde. If a campaign begins to strike the teacher longevity pay from the new budget bill, here's betting his fingerprints will be all over it.

Nobody says no to John Goedde.


Originally posted at

The editorial posted here is provided by permission of its original publisher and does not necessarily reflect the views of Idaho Public Television.

Return To Idaho Opinions

Legislative & Political News


Idaho News Media

Newspapers and News sites